Tuesday, Jul. 14, 2020

All you can eat sushi round-up

Written By:


November 14, 2012


Posted In:

All you can eat sushi round-up

All you can eat sushi round-up All you can eat sushi round-up because more is good, but unlimited is better!

This mindset has led to a booming market for All-You-Can-Eat sushi restaurants. After all, what is better than stuffing yourself silly with sushi, right?!

Unfortunately, I have long outgrown the yearning for food comas after such all you can eat dinners. If you too, prefer a less intense not-competition-for-who-can-eat-50-pieces-dragon-roll meal,  I suggest Watami, Niko Niko, or Sakura Island. None of them are truly authentic or owned by Japanese, but they do offer higher quality and beautifully presented dishes. Worth a try.

Amongst the various all you can eat, there is really minimal difference between price ($25/person for weekend dinner) and menu. Some may have crazier rolls than others, but thats about it. Hence, I have concluded that the real differential factor for determining which is the best all you can eat will be service, and/or quality. Since all you can eat targets greedy hungry customers, I assume that these customers would prefer mediocre food fast than quality food slow.

First Impression:

Has anyone else noticed that all you can eat typically uses the same tableware? You can actually get those at Walmart!

On the typical-all you can eat Table for Maple Seaweed Salad and/or edamame to start the meal. If you are at a non all you can eat, I suggest skipping these as the tiny serving of salads are generally overpriced at $5.

Salmon sashimi is my favourite. I find that other raw fish at all you can eat are usually too bland/low quality. If you hate raw fish, skip all you can eat. You’ll never get your money’s worth by eating the other waaaay-toooo-filling stuff!

And yes, I am one of those people who can stomach 50 pieces of sashimi at one go.

Other good options will be meat skewers and shrimp tempura.

We also enjoy the occasional spicy salmon roll. The only mayo acceptable in sushi should be spicy mayo! So weird but so good! Rainbow roll is a nice spin to the old school California, if you are feeling a little adventurous.


The Good, The Bad, and The Maybe 

Sushi Stars is my go-to all you can eat in KW. I have been to their sister restaurant in Hamilton, but definitely prefer the KW location. They also offer avocado milkshakes – definitely not Japanese, but creamily decadent and a must-try.

Sushi Boat, on the other hand, was a total disaster. They offered a half-price deal a couple weeks ago, and I thought it was the perfect opportunity to verify their reputation of terrible service and food. In retrospect, that was probably not a wise decision. Restaurants get constant bad reviews for a reason. Imagine Y’s reaction when I told him –

We’re going to Sushi Boat tonight! I heard that it is really terrible so I bought this coupon for 50% off! Wow, I am so excited to see how terrible they are!

Consistent with other reviews, the service was horrendous. We were there on a Friday night and waited for >30 minutes before we were served. Not only is slow service a taboo for all you can eat restaurants, but highly unacceptable for one with less than five tables filled! Our server justified that it was due to another table ordering too much, and the chef had to finish all their orders before starting on any of ours.

I am not too sure how restaurants usually juggle orders from different tables, but I think staggering orders by alternating tables is probably a more viable option? You gotta keep everyone happy!

The unapologetic tasteless sashimi finally arrived after 40 minutes.

Failed California roll. Two pieces of crab meat and too much rice. Where’s my avocado?

Sigh, we gave up after our first round of orders and headed to MacD next door. **Update: Seems like Sushi Boat closed down? Need to verify that but bye Sushi Boat, I will not miss you.

A surprising place to go for all you can eat sushi is actually Spring Rolls at Conestoga Mall. Spring Rolls sashimi triumphs over numerous other all you can eat in the region, perhaps due to their corporate size and ability to purchase fresher fish?

Their all you can eat menu also includes Thai food and Dimsum. Triple the value, triple the confusion as to what to order.


Other all you can eat in the region:

If you are at…

Sushi 99 – try their Mackerel sashimi. Busy place, good alternative if the line-up at Ben Thanh is too long and you are lazy to drive somewhere else for food.

O Yummy Sushi – they sometimes serve weird warm sushi, but some of my friends swear that this is the best place in town for AYCE. A hit-or-miss, but nice owner. He once allowed us greedy-folks-who-ordered-too-much to brownbag leftovers without extra charge!

Ye’s Sushi – uhm, whatcha doing there? I really wish they’ll stop expanding because they are seriously terrible.

Yummyaki – leave.

Maple’s Preference Ranking:

  1. Sushi Star
  2. Spring Rolls
  3. Sushi 99
  4. O’ Yummy Sushi

Not worth your money: 

  1. Sushi Boat
  2. Ye’s Sushi
  3. Yummyaki

Thanks Maple for guest blogging for us. She’s great isn’t she? For more food blogging please visit Maple at TableforMaple.com. Maple was named after a Maple Tree outside her family’s house. Thankfully, they did not have a Chestnut tree or her site would be called TableforChestnut. Maple decided to start writing about the delicious food (and occasionally things to do) in the Kitchener-Waterloo region because many people don’t realize how much there is to eat/do in this little town!

Share This Article

Related News

15th Annual Chicken Wing Competition!
Roaster’s Delight: A Guide to the Best Independent Coffee Roasters in Waterloo
Valentine’s Day Idea’s in Kitchener-Waterloo

About Author


Keith helps home buyers understand homes, schools and neighbourhoods in Kitchener Waterloo. He is an author, an award-winning realtor and an agent of change. On Twitter @kdmarshall. Online at keithmarshall.ca.

(2) Readers Comments

  1. Dave Humphrey
    November 14, 2012 at 9:57 am

    Interesting blog. We went to Sushi Boat twice, both times on a Saturday at noon and had no issues with speed or quality. Sushi Star is definitely better but our favourite so far is Nara Sushi in the Sunrise Plaza at Ottawa and Fischer Hallman. Give it a try.

    • kdmarshall
      November 14, 2012 at 10:04 am

      I thought Sushi Boat was OK, but noisy. Nara was excellent, I agree.

Leave A Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *